The Tic Tac Dough theme song gave me the heebie-jeebies as a kid, prolly because of the squiggly Moog sound. When it aired on USA, I avoided the show because of that theme. Now I love it.
The wall behind the contestants on Remote Control also scared the crap out of me, esp. when they\'d have the cast members \"welcoming\" the contestant backstage. Can\'t remember what he said, but my older cousin used to make up some lie about what kind of torture those poor contestants endured once they got backstage.
ETA: It never bothered me on USA, but the SANDY FRANK PRESENTS Scanimate graphics at the beginning of Face the Music creeped me out when it aired on the Family Channel.
Shows that superimpose eggcrates for win totals/countdown clocks still creep me out a bit. Not to the point of where I cover my eyes, but just the whole tackiness of it all. I think Dawson\'s Feud is the one exception.